Is Your HR Department Like Kathy Griffin?
September 29th, 2008
I’ve been on the road quite a bit lately so my wife and I decided to treat ourselves and go see Kathy Griffin live at DAR’s Constitution Hall here in Washington, DC. If you’re not familiar with Kathy, she is renowned for taking her real-life encounters and incorporating them into her comedy act using sarcasm, mockery and outright degradation. Her material can be a cringer to some, but if you go in with the attitude that she’s making fun of everyone (including herself), she is absolutely hilarious.
Whether Kathy is your cup of tea or not, something she said in her show last night got me thinking. Because her material is sourced from interactions with celebrities, they often ask her for a side deal to exclude their encounters from her act. In other words, they seek reassurance that the conversation was private, privileged and wouldn’t come back to haunt them. Of course, doing so would hurt Kathy’s “business”, so exclusions are obviously not in her interest. Often times this has unexpected consequences and can makes A-listers want to avoid her at all costs, including some suing her for her statements. Thus, our title question stands - is your HR department like Kathy Griffin?
I pose this comparison because I have witnessed a shift in HR’s brand perception over the years. There was a time when HR was believed to represent the best interests of employees within the context of the employer. This former persona ensured confidentiality, safe harbor and a highly privileged set of interactions. Although this is a gross generalization and oversimplification, most employees today view HR as the enforcer of rules and regs, a literal mouth-piece of the executive committee. So, like Kathy Griffin, many employees fear that anything they share with HR will not only get back to their manager, but negatively impact their prospects for future growth in the organization.
This may be an unfair comparison as many HR professionals entered this vocation to truly help people. However, I have unfortunately been in the presence of hundreds of “HR Kathy Griffins” who cannot wait to share the juiciest bit of gossip and innermost secrets of the employees they support. But unlike Kathy’s first amendment lawyer, your company may not protect you from litigation resulting from such indiscretions. I have witnessed HR personnel fired on the spot for this behavior, but more often it is the employee who pays the ultimate price.
Let’s face it - HR is a tough job and sometimes you want to let out a little steam. Or perhaps you feel you are duty bound to go directly to an employee’s manager the moment a conversation is over. My only request is to recognize that any action will have both intended and unintended consequences for you, management and the employee. Be thoughtful and put yourself in their shoes. Either that or quit your job, dye your hair red and start working the clubs.
Let’s keep the conversation going.




The numbers keep adding up and the impact on the global workforce could be staggering. A litany of venerable and long-standing institutions have fallen victim to the current state of our nation’s increasingly fragile economic reality. Let’s look at today’s potential body count:
The good folks at
I’ve had fourteen days respite from the cacophony of noise which swirls about the heads of our glorious HR market. I haven’t picked up a trade magazine, attended a conference or drawn obvious human resources correlations using metaphorical hurricanes, presidential candidates or Michael Phelps. No press interviews. No white papers. No self-important statements predicting the rise and fall of Vendor X or Strategy Y. No table and no seat.
It’s an inevitable and sometimes uncomfortable situation. You’re in a meeting or on a conference call and not everyone has arrived, requiring you to banter with the client/boss/partner mano y mano. How do you engage in small talk and build rapport? If you get nervous and start to stammer, what do you do? Do people even care about small talk in today’s fast-paced business world?
It all began when I was a young boy growing up in the suburbs of Milwaukee. My older brother and I would turn on the sprinklers at dusk, sipping on Kool-Aid as we waited for the sun to drop and the grass to fully saturate. Grabbing our flashlights, we’d slosh onto the soggy lawn to stalk the objects of our desire - Nightcrawlers. These are the big, fat, juicy earthworms that are the lifeblood of a Midwestern fisherman. Squirming and diving, the faceless creatures would be collected en masse, dropped by the dozen onto a dirt bed within cheap styrofoam containers. We had an enterprise, and signs all over town pointed to our house, where “M & M Worms” (Mike and Mark…very creative, I know) was headquartered.
In watching coverage of the games last evening, my wife and I were discussing the overwhelming complexity involved in managing and deploying the Olympics. With so many nations each carrying such unique agendas and goals, what overarching principles are applied to such a multifaceted assembly? What procedures are in place to ensure proper philosophical governance of an event with such global implications?
Most employees walk around every day with a ready supply of hand grenades. Some are thrown at coworkers during times of duress. Others get rolled into the boss’ office when credit is taken for something you worked weekends to complete. But the most explosive, destructive and damaging we save for ourselves. This is the overarching point of Gen Xer Jason Seiden’s sarcastic book, “